An Indian view on history, current affairs and politics

May 27, 2018

Who is the real liberal?

The recent controversy over Penguin India’s decision to withdraw and pulp Wendy Doniger’s book “The Hindus: An alternate history” has once again sparked the debate about freedom of expression issues in India. The decision to withdraw the book was taken by publisher following a legal battle with a group of Hindus led by President of Sanatan Dharma foundation, Dinanath Batra. The objection raised by this group relates not only to the factual inaccuracies in the content which for the most part shows shoddy research and poor translation of Hindu texts on the authors part but more importantly the author uses outlandish assumptions to conclude extremely obscene and denigrating ideas about Hindu gods and religious scriptures. Throughout the book, Doniger analyzes Hindu Gods and Goddesses using discredited psychosexual Freudian theories, resulting in speculations. Doniger uses selective quotations from obscure and non-original, peripheral and ignorant references with a bizarre emphasis on sexuality and eroticism. Before i proceed, its prudent to share some excerpts from the book for the benefit of readers.

Page 40 If the motto of Watergate was Follow the money, the motto of the
history of Hinduism could well be Follow the monkey or, more often Follow
the horse.

Page 112 – The author alleges that in Rigveda 10.62, it is implied that a
woman may find her own brother in her bed!

Page 128 – The book likens the Vedic devotee worshipping different Vedic
deities to a lying and a philandering boyfriend cheating on his girlfriend (s).

Page 225 -Dasharathas son is certainly lustful… Rama knows all too well what people said about Dasharatha; when Lakshmana learns that Rama has been exiled, he says, The king is perverse, old, and addicted to sex, driven by lust (2.18.3)

Pg 571- It is alleged that in a hymn from Saint Kshetrayyas poetry, God rapes the women devotees.

Above are few excerpts that were cited as derogatory to Hindu beliefs not to mention several inaccuracies that actually turn the book into a product based on imagination rather than research. It is appalling then that such a book was often referred to by students of Indic studies. Equally appalling is that Wendy is considered an authority on Indic and Hinduism studies even though she has an academic background in Muslim studies.A closer look at her work clearly reveals a pattern of Hindu bashing all the while defending and often praising Muslim and Christian conquest of India. In this 779 page book, many themes are touched upon, she jumps from one topic to another; it is laced with personal editorials, folksy turn of the phrase, and colloquial idiom. She can always pull from her bulky bag of tricks the most damning story—Vedic, Puranic, folk, oral, vernacular—to demean, damage and disparage Hinduism.

The book is written, entirely from within the same western, modern, secular-academic point of view that has largely rejected a sacred vision of the cosmos and that has largely dismissed whatever tried-and-tested systems of spiritual practice we may once have had. Doniger conveys almost none of the spiritual vitality and seems not to recognize any of the practical spiritual knowledge that other writers and teachers show to be embedded in Hindu scriptures. If anything, she belittles these aspects of Hinduism in just that sort of way that modernized people as a group tend, unfortunately, to do, believing themselves to know better and to be more sophisticated than people who maintain their ancient traditions.

Coming to the recent controversy, It’s important to note that this is not a new book. The book has been around for several years now and the content of the book was challenged by academicians through articles, seminars and columns. It was only after Wendy’s book was awarded Ramnath Goenka award in 2012, that a group of academics decided to challenge the book in courts. Remember these people are not a bunch of street thugs who were out burning the book and issuing threats and fatwas but noted academics. It was following this court case that penguin settled for an out of court settlement and decided to withdraw the book and pulp it.The so called liberal intelligentsia reacted along predicted lines except that their attack this time was more vicious scathing and relied mostly on misinformation to slam the Hindus in general and the litigants in particular. The litigants were called cretins, idiots, bigots, fascists, hate mongers, morons, bigots and a lot more.

In one fell swoop the outraged liberals banded together to generalize this episode as Hindu fascism led by BJP and RSS. Does a Hindu not associated with these groups not have a right to protest against unjust denigration of his religion. Does anyone realize if Wendy had attempted a fraction of what she did with The Hindus in certain countries, she would have been stoned to death. The protest against Wendy was peaceful, almost docile and within legal framework of the country. How is taking a legal recourse to a dispute fascist? How is the legal case against Wendy’s book different from a defamation case one files against deliberate insult or a case filed against hate speeches?

The protest by Indian liberals was more vocal and vitriolic than their western counterparts even though no one missed a chance at bashing Hindu nationalists. In their urge to appear more liberal and get noted by western media, a lot commented without even understanding the issue at all. A lot called it a ban when in fact it was a voluntary withdrawal by the publisher. The litigants were well within their right to file a court case where they had equal chance of losing the case and per their statements they were prepared to accept such a result. The publisher on the other hand could have fought the case to the bitter end. Publishers also had the option to remove the excerpts objected to by the litigants instead they chose to withdraw. The liberals however continued to blame the litigants even though it was the publisher who failed to defend the writer. How many of these liberal intellectuals said a word when Dr. Subramanyam Swamy’s, Taslima Nasreen’s or Jitendra Bhargava’s work were withdrawn. The reason for such hypocrisy lies in the fact that unlike Islamists, Hindus do not react violently. Secondly this gives them visibility and recognition in eyes of western media which has a history of rewarding Hindu bashing.

The hypocrisy of left liberals is exposed in their reaction to any form of protest by Hindus. When an offensive content is challenged academically, they term it trolling the writer. When protesting on street they call it violence by fascist fundamentalists and when challenged legally they heap abuse wrapped in ignorance and of course challenge the law. Is it strange that overwhelming majority of liberals who didn’t find anything wrong with Wendy’s book are atheists. How can you even identify with the sense of hurt of Hindus when you don’t believe their scriptures and faith. Funny how Congress and AAP spokespersons joined the attack even though their own record in banning books, sites, boycotting criticism on TV is appalling. Seems all sorts of scavengers and bottom feeders have got together to feast on the dead and the dying. Its ironical how withdrawal of Wendy’s book sparks freedom of speech debate but her deliberate distortion and denigration of Hinduism doesn’t. What if Owaisi who famously claimed to kill all Hindus in 15 mins writes a book stating the same?

Those who’re waxing eloquence on US for its 1st amendment allowing for freedom of speech should know US is the top most requester and blocker of content on Internet. Before you think of the reasons why they do so , remember Internet is universal, laws governing it and the reasons to block it should be universal as well. There is a need to debate. Freedom of expression cannot be taken as freedom to insult and hate. We’ve not yet reached the Utopian state where responsible behavior comes before claims of freedom to do or say anything. Penguin India’s explanation for withdrawing the book is bizarre. It was evident that cost of litigation was too much for them to pursue the writer’s cause, yet they chose to hide behind excuse of Indian laws and threat to its employees. How can you blame a law when you didn’t test it in the court? Seems they judged the case even before the court could. Hindus genuinely hurt by Wendy’s book continue to be at the receiving end of an over zealous mob of self proclaimed liberals while the rest shine in their ignorant best. Sometimes i feel Hinduism has survived despite attacks, insults and denigration not because of an inherent resilience but an indifferent attitude. Hindus just don’t care!

  • Mang Mify

    There should be more voices coming from each and every corner in this way then only these pseudo-secular “so called” liberals will mind their language, until then they will keep abusing Hindus no matter if they protest peacefully or violently for such type of insults.

  • SS

    The English press controlled from outside India with its cronies in the press and so called activists have been twisting and denigrating the word “Secularism”. They have defined it to mean Hindu or Hinduism bashing. This is a very sad state of affairs.
    They talk of freedom of speech of an individual forgettiing the freedom of the rest of millions of hindus who are offended. Denigrating Hindu saints and deities has come to mean Secularism. They must HANG THEIR HEAD IN SHAME. Hindus have historically been the most tolerant. However, others have mistaken this tolerance to be weakness. So once in a while, when some one protests this type of atrocious denigration, we expect others regardless of their religious conviction to support such a protest instead of joining the chorus. This is called SECULARISM. I call upon every Indian, regardless of his religious conviction to rise up as one and speak up in one voice aginst this type of outrage so that no one – a foreigner or an indian dares to hurt the sentiments of a fellow Indian in the name of freedom of expression. This will be the true test and demonstration of the unity of our nation.

  • Soham

    ‘Invading the Sacred”. It is now available for free download through Rajiv Malhotra’s website. Please read it and find out the truth. It is sad…..Our english media will not do any research themselves and they will not invite the scholars like Rajeev Malhotra …….because it does not suite liberal leftist tune and tenure….of fish market debate.

  • FreeedomOfExpression

    India is becoming more intolerant by the day.

    • rama karupaiah

      Freedom of expression or for that matter any freedom in a democracy is circumscribed by anothers personal freedom and right to his / her beliefs. This is a basic principle of law.I suggest you check this out before shooting off your mouth.

  • Ratnesh

    I would suggest if this was a threat to freedom of speech ,then what happened to the voice of Nathuram Godse “Why I killed Gandhi” , and what about Taslima Nasreen and about other Writer who have written on Muslim community. Fatwa has been issued and they call if freedom of speech. Don’t force Hindus to adopt violence method to put their voice…..We believe in non-violence but time has proved if forced we didn’t hesitated to take weapons in self defence.

    Let me see if govt approves these books and so called voice of “Freedom of Speech” support for lifting the ban from the belo mentioned books :

    Rangila Rasul –The booklet purportedly described Prophet Muhammad’s relationship with women.

    Ayesha – This book means Fav. Wife of Muhammad.

    The Moor’s Last Sigh – In this book ,it has been said that a dog has been Named by J.L. Nehru…..

    Islam: A Concept of Political World Invasion ,, the list is never ending…..

  • disqus_dor1YsFNCG

    The problem is never with Hindus, there’s a special category (growing) people known as SUPER_HINDU. They are larger than life, self obsessed liberals (the one’s which you have described in your article) who would go to any length to denigrade their own religion just becuse it is more kewl to do so and it sounds being secular.

  • Pingback: fast cash

  • Pingback: Blue Coaster33

  • Pingback: watch free movies online

  • Pingback: streaming movies

  • Pingback: lan hurtige penge nu

  • Pingback: laan penge nu uden renter

  • Pingback: parking

  • Pingback: parking

  • Pingback: pay per day loans plan

  • Pingback: water ionizer

  • Pingback: pay day loans

  • Pingback: dewalt small electricians pouch

  • Pingback: locksmith gainesville ga

  • Pingback: check this out

  • Pingback: plumbing fixtures discount

  • Pingback: browse around this web-site

  • Pingback: Payday loans

  • Pingback: house blue

  • Pingback: offshore electrician jobs africa

  • Pingback: electrician jobs dublin georgia

  • Pingback: HD Coloring Pages

  • Pingback: alkaline water brands

  • Pingback: pay plan

  • Pingback: electricity

  • Pingback: water ionizer

  • Pingback: alkaline water

  • Pingback: alkaline water

  • Pingback:

  • Pingback: read more

  • Pingback: I was reading this

  • Pingback: Dungeon

  • Pingback: binaural

  • Pingback: jogos friv

  • Pingback: 忠誠千其唔好去啊, 我都中左招

  • Pingback: Maria Smith

  • Pingback: Political Diyala

  • Pingback: Walkie Talkie Test

  • Pingback: Hyderabad Corporate Event Managers

  • Pingback: Christ Gospel Church Cult

  • Pingback: discover this info here

  • Pingback: must watch

  • Pingback: address

  • Pingback: black and white bedroom ideas

  • Pingback: jayne herring

  • Pingback: Cialis purchasing

  • Pingback: Low cost viagra 20mg

  • Pingback: Cialis generique

  • Pingback: Viagra viagra levitra

  • Pingback: Discount cialis

  • Pingback: Generic cialis

  • Pingback: Low cost viagra 20mg

  • Pingback: Cialis 5mg prix

  • Pingback: Cialis generic

  • Pingback: Buy cialis online

  • Pingback: Generic cialis